St. Augustine, Florida · open today
Casablanca Inn on the Bay
The inn's own account of Prohibition: the widow who ran it took the rumrunners as lodgers and as a lover, and stood in an upstairs window with a lantern to signal the boats on the bay whether the coast was clear. The building was the Matanzas Hotel then. It is a bayfront address with a martini bar and a cafe, which is the trade it has now.
- Ask for
- Not recorded
- Opened
- Not recorded
- Where
- St. AugustineFlorida
- Still open
- Yesbooks direct
What people report
The signal story is the one the inn tells, along with the occasional guest who says the window is still occupied.
Careful with this one. This is the hotel's own telling, not an encyclopedia's — it is a good story about a building that really was a boarding house during Prohibition, and the ghost is the part you either take or leave.
Plan the night
24 Avenida Menendez, St. Augustine, Florida · on a map
Booking.com and Expedia are searched for Casablanca Inn on the Bay in St. Augustine, and Agoda opens St. Augustine. If an engine does not list this hotel — several of these inns are too small to be on them at all — you land on the city's results rather than on an empty page. To be sure of the room, book direct. Dates stay in your browser until you click; nothing is booked here and no link is paid for.
Questions worth asking before you book
Can you stay at Casablanca Inn on the Bay?
Casablanca Inn on the Bay is a working hotel in St. Augustine, Florida. Book direct through the hotel's own site, or look for it by name on Booking.com, Expedia. Nothing is booked here and no link on this page is paid for.
Does Casablanca Inn on the Bay have a haunted room?
Nothing in the record names a room here. Ask at the desk — the staff at a hotel with this one's reputation usually know which room the stories follow.
Is Casablanca Inn on the Bay really haunted?
The claim is folklore, not a finding. The inn's own account of Prohibition: the widow who ran it took the rumrunners as lodgers and as a lover, and stood in an upstairs window with a lantern to signal the boats on the bay whether the coast was clear. The building was the Matanzas Hotel then. It is a bayfront address with a martini bar and a cafe, which is the trade it has now. The account above is what Casablanca Inn on the Bay records, and it is guest and staff testimony — the kind of evidence that is interesting precisely because it cannot be checked. Where the record contradicts the story, this page says so above.
Where is Casablanca Inn on the Bay?
24 Avenida Menendez, St. Augustine, Florida. Open it on a map. Coordinates 29.8948, -81.3117, from OpenStreetMap (Nominatim).
What else is said to be haunted within forty miles
Straight-line distance to every place in the Haunting Index — the 261 addresses Wikipedia's reportedly-haunted category carries, which is a record of what is said rather than a survey of what is. The dataset's gaps are real: a town with two entries is not a town with two ghosts.
- 1.5 miSt. Augustine LightLighthouse in Florida, US
- 35 miKing House (Mayport)
- 37 miPublic School Number FourPublic school in Jacksonville, Florida, USA
Written from: Casablanca Inn on the Bay on the hotel's own site, read 2026-11-16. Official site checked the same day. Photograph by Kiran891, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Not in the Haunting Index. This entry is here on the hotel's own account, in these words:
“The proprietor of the hotel was an enterprising widow of high class, who was never one to pass up on an opportunity... She would stand in an upstairs window with a lantern, signalling to the ships when the coast was clear and when it was not.”
Also in Florida: The Vinoy (St. Petersburg) · St. Francis Inn (St. Augustine) · all 25